You list a couch, a phone, or a bike, and within minutes a buyer appears. No haggling, no questions, ready to pay right now, and always through Venmo. That eagerness is the tell. The Venmo Marketplace scam has become one of the most common tricks played on everyday sellers, and it works because the scammer never actually pays anything. They fake the appearance of a payment, then use your own confusion about how Venmo works to pull money out of you or walk away with your item.
How this scam works
A buyer responds to your listing almost immediately, agrees to your full price without seeing the item, and pushes to pay by Venmo right away.
They claim they sent the money but got an error, and send you a screenshot as proof. The screenshot is fabricated. No payment exists in your Venmo balance.
They ask for your email address. Soon an official-looking Venmo email arrives saying the payment is on hold and will be released once you ship the item or confirm shipping details. Venmo never does this. The email is fake, sent from a lookalike address.
In the nastiest version, the email says the buyer paid from a business account, so you must upgrade your account to receive the funds, and the upgrade costs money. The buyer promises to cover it, sometimes even faking an extra payment for it, and asks you to send the fee back.
Whatever you send is your own real money going to the scammer, and anything you ship is gone. The original payment never existed at any point.
What it sounds like
Buyer: I sent the payment but Venmo says your account cannot receive it. You need to upgrade to a business account, it charges a $200 fee. I already sent the $200 extra, just send it back after you upgrade.
You: No money is in my Venmo balance, so nothing was paid. Real payments arrive instantly, and there is no receiving upgrade. This is a scam.
Red flags
- A buyer who agrees instantly, sight unseen, and insists on Venmo or another instant payment app.
- A payment screenshot instead of money actually appearing in your Venmo balance.
- Any email saying a payment is pending, on hold, or waiting for shipping info or an account upgrade.
- Talk of business accounts, receiving limits, or fees the buyer will reimburse.
- A buyer who asks for your email address for the payment. Venmo does not need it.
How to sell safely with payment apps
- Open the Venmo app yourself and trust only one thing: money sitting in your balance. Not screenshots, not emails, not pending anything.
- Sell locally, meet in a public place, and do not hand over the item until you have confirmed the balance in your own app.
- Never pay a fee, upgrade, or refund an overpayment to receive money. Receiving money on Venmo is free and instant.
- For shipped sales, use the marketplace's own checkout with purchase protection instead of a payment app.
- Real Venmo email comes from an address ending in venmo.com. Anything else claiming to be Venmo is fake, and you can verify any suspicious sender with our scam checker.
How to report this scam
Also report the buyer inside Facebook Marketplace, and forward fake Venmo emails to [email protected] so Venmo can act on the sender. See the full reporting guide for every US agency and what each one handles.
Frequently asked questions
Does Venmo put payments on hold until you ship?
No. A real Venmo payment lands in your app balance immediately. Any email or screenshot saying a payment is pending, on hold, or waiting for shipping information or an account upgrade is fake.
Do I need a Venmo business account to receive a payment?
No. Anyone can send money to a personal Venmo account. The business account upgrade story, especially one that involves the buyer sending extra money or you paying a fee, is a scam script.
Is it safe to accept Venmo on Facebook Marketplace?
For local, in-person sales it can be, if you open your own Venmo app and confirm the money is in your balance before handing over the item. Never rely on a buyer's screenshot or an email, and never ship an item on the promise of a pending payment. The same rules apply to Zelle and Cash App, and our guide to Zelle and bank transfer scams covers that side of it.
Back to all scammers